Summary CertiK checked two of ten GL1 principles. The public release discloses no findings. Issuers keep freeze and clawback powers. […]
The post XRP Ledger’s Big Bank Test Covered Only 2 of 10 Rules appeared first on Coindoo.
Summary
- CertiK checked two of ten GL1 principles.
- The public release discloses no findings.
- Issuers keep freeze and clawback powers.
- New amendments can outpace the attestation.
The XRP Ledger Foundation said on November 18 that XRPL is the first public, permissionless layer-1 blockchain to have those two principles independently verified, citing a CertiK attestation report dated November 13.
Two principles verified, eight graded at home
The Foundation completed a self-attestation against all ten principles of GL1’s Market Infrastructure Toolkit. Its answers cover governance, legal basis, settlement finality, operational and cyber resilience, access and participation, and data and privacy. CertiK reviewed only the responses and evidence filed under Architecture and Resiliency. GL1’s toolkit website shows the same split.
What did CertiK find? The release doesn’t say. It publishes no findings, quotes no one from CertiK and leaves out the XRPL software version under review. Anyone who wants more than the headline has to ask for the report.
The harder part sits inside the framework. The toolkit builds on the CPMI-IOSCO Principles for Financial Market Infrastructures, the Digital Asset Securities Control Principles and the Global Blockchain Business Council’s risk mitigation framework, and many of its controls assume a single operator runs the network. XRPL has none. Where a control didn’t fit, the Foundation explained how protocol design, open-source governance, the amendment process and issuer compliance tools handle the same risk instead.
So a bank’s risk team isn’t reading a checklist. It’s reading a translation, and it has to judge whether each substitute does the work of the control it replaces.
XRPL also isn’t the only name on GL1’s list. Just one other entry carries a CertiK verification label, and it runs a permissioned network. That explains why the Foundation’s “first” claim leans so hard on the words “public, permissionless.”
Named on GL1’s toolkit page
Base
Broadridge DLR
HSBC Orion
Kinexys by J.P. Morgan
Partior – CertiK-verified
Prividium (Matter Labs)
Solana
Tempo
T-REX Network
XRP Ledger – CertiK-verified
GL1 thanks these organisations for “self-attestations and/or feedback” and does not mark the status of the unlabelled entries.
Who backs GL1, and what they didn’t sign
The Monetary Authority of Singapore convened the original GL1 initiative with global banks and policymakers. On November 4, HSBC, Kinexys by J.P. Morgan, MUFG Bank, Societe Generale-FORGE and Standard Chartered turned it into an industry-led non-profit based in Singapore. The working group behind the toolkit includes the Bank of England, Banque de France and MAS.
Heavy names. None of them approved XRPL.
The Foundation’s release says so directly: the attestation isn’t certification, approval or endorsement by GL1, any central bank, regulator or participating institution, and it isn’t a finding that XRPL meets the standards the toolkit draws on. It tells institutions to run their own assessments.
Foundation Executive Director Brett Mollin pitched the exercise as an answer to fatigue. Institutions, he said, don’t need “another white paper” arguing that public ledgers can carry tokenized assets; they need evidence their compliance teams can map. Fair enough. But that map ends at the network. Follow one payment and you can see where the bank’s own work begins.
Who can move the bank’s token?
Picture a bank sending an issuer-backed dollar token to an approved counterparty. Before anything reaches the ledger, it needs answers. What does the token represent? What can the holder redeem? Who inside the bank may sign?
XRPL now gives it finer control over that last question. Permission Delegation went live on mainnet on October 8 through the PermissionDelegationV1_1 amendment, replacing an earlier version that never reached mainnet after a bug surfaced in testing. An account can hand a delegate up to ten specific permissions, so routine signing runs on limited keys while the master key stays offline. Delegates can’t change keys or grant themselves extra powers.
The protocol enforces each permission. The bank decides who holds them, how it guards the keys and what happens when an employee leaves. Coindoo’s look at XRPL’s new wallet controls walks through the setup.
In the ledger doesn’t mean paid
The bank submits. A success message comes back. Nothing has settled yet.
XRPL’s finality documentation separates that early response from the result recorded in a validated ledger, and validated ledgers hold failures too. Some failed transactions still pay a fee and land in the record. An operations system that spots the transaction in a ledger and stops checking could credit a customer for money that never moved.
So the bank’s software has to read the final result code and the balance changes the transaction actually made. Partial payments add a trap: the delivered amount can fall short of the amount field, and only the delivered figure counts.
Dropped connections cause the nastier problem, because the bank can’t tell whether the payment failed, succeeded or is still pending. XRPL’s submission guidance tells applications to give every transaction a last valid ledger, so a lost instruction expires at a known point, and to confirm the original’s fate before sending a replacement. Skip that check and the bank can pay twice.
The issuer keeps a hand on the balance
The payment validates. Can the recipient move those tokens next week?
That depends on the issuer, not the network. Under XRPL’s freeze rules, an issuer can freeze a single holder’s trust line, which blocks that holder from sending the tokens anywhere except back to the issuer. A deep freeze also stops receiving and trading. A global freeze hits every holder of everything the issuer has issued. Issuers who want to give all of this up can set No Freeze, a permanent flag that only the master key can sign.
Clawback works on a stricter clock. An issuer has to switch it on before its account holds any trust lines, offers, escrows or similar objects, so it can’t bolt clawback onto a token already in circulation. Clawback and No Freeze can’t coexist, and neither tool touches XRP.
None of this rewrites history; a clawback is a fresh transaction. It does change what the bank’s customer actually holds. Those settings sit on the issuer’s account where anyone can query them, and they reveal more about one token’s risk than a network-wide attestation does.
Brazil shows the issuer side at work. In a September 29 announcement, Ripple and depository CSD BR said XRPL now mirrors records of BTG Pactual fund shares as Multi-Purpose Tokens. CSD BR’s systems remain the official record. The ledger lets authorized participants audit that the two match, and only Brazilian corporate and banking clients that clear KYC and anti-money-laundering checks can join.
CSD BR also keeps the power to freeze holdings or claw them back when a regulator or court orders it. Whatever the ledger shows, the depository’s register and Brazilian law decide ownership. Coindoo’s report on XRPL’s entry into Brazil’s fund system has the project background.
An attestation of a network that won’t sit still
XRPL changes through amendments. One takes effect after it holds support from more than 80% of trusted validators, meaning those on the default Unique Node List, for two straight weeks.
Those changes come often. Permission Delegation arrived on October 8. Within weeks, validators enabled fixCleanup3_4_0, which closed a gap that let a delegated burn permission create new tokens.
The Foundation says it intends to refresh its assessment as the toolkit evolves and new amendments activate. Today’s readers have a narrower problem. Because the release doesn’t name the software version CertiK reviewed, a risk team can’t tell which of this autumn’s changes the attestation covers. Ask for that first.
The post XRP Ledger’s Big Bank Test Covered Only 2 of 10 Rules appeared first on Coindoo.
Source: https://coindoo.com/xrp-ledgers-big-bank-test-covered-only-2-of-10-rules/
More Crypto News
Check our Market Overview
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Always conduct your own research (DYOR).





